Crothersville's Favorite

Crothersville Gets Its Best Burgers Right Here on US 31

From flame-grilled burgers to fresh-baked goods, Shake Shack & Grill brings the taste of Crothersville together under one roof — quality food, honest prices, no fuss.

Call to Order View Menu

Fresh burgers and grilled food at Shake Shack & Grill in Crothersville

Flame-Grilled. Fresh-Made.

Every single day on S. Armstrong Street

Fresh

Local ingredients, made daily

US 31

Easy stop on S. Armstrong St.

Fresh bakery items at Shake Shack & Grill

Grilled classics at Shake Shack & Grill Crothersville

Scroll

Quality Ingredients

Locally sourced when possible

Honest Prices

Great value every day

Right on US 31

Easy access, free parking

Made with Care

Every sandwich, every day

Our Menu

What We're Serving Up

From smash burgers to grilled favorites and fresh bakery items — everything made to order, right here in Crothersville.

Classic and specialty burgers at Shake Shack and Grill

POPULAR

Burgers & Smashes

Flame-grilled patties, melted cheese, fresh buns, and all the fixings — built the way you like them.

Call to order

Grilled entrees and plates at Shake Shack and Grill

Grill Classics

Chicken fingers, fish sandwiches, pork chops, and more — hearty plates cooked right in front of you.

Call to order

Fresh baked goods and pastries at Shake Shack and Grill

Bakery & Sweets

Fresh-baked breads, pastries, and sweets — the kind that makes you stop by just for dessert.

Call to order

Sides & Shakes

Crispy fries, loaded tots, hand-spun shakes, and all the sides that make a meal complete.

Call to order

Cold Drinks

Soft drinks, iced tea, lemonade, and frosty shakes — perfectly paired with any meal.

Call to order

Catering & Events

Hosting a gathering in Crothersville? We'll bring the food — burgers, grilled plates, and bakery spreads ready for your crowd.

Ask About Catering

Interior of Shake Shack and Grill in Crothersville

Fresh food being prepared at Shake Shack and Grill

Serving food at Shake Shack and Grill Crothersville

About Us

A Crothersville Staple Since Day One

Shake Shack & Grill sits right on S. Armstrong Street along US 31 — the kind of spot where neighbors stop by for a quick burger on the way home or pull in for a full meal with the family.

We keep things simple: quality ingredients, honest portions, and a menu that covers everything from flame-grilled burgers and grilled favorites to fresh bakery goods. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or planning something bigger, we've got you covered right here in town.

US 31

Prime location in town

Fresh

Made daily, served daily

Find Us in Crothersville

Gallery